Prendergast can be tortured by the complexity of choice, like a dog with two bones as Devo once sang, but as far as the AFL is concerned the truly important decisions were made by Watts and Naitanui some time ago.
That is, in the increasingly expensive struggle between sports for the best athletic talent in the land, the two teenagers chose Australian football.
Watts, who has just completed his year 11 exams at Melbourne’s Brighton Grammar School, was described by basketball insiders two years ago, when he was still a baby-faced 15-year-old, as one of the best prospects the hoops community had seen in 20 years.
He was the holder of an AIS basketball scholarship and more recently advised by basketball officialdom that serious consideration was being given to the idea of drafting him into the Boomers squad for the London Olympic Games in 2012.
When football came calling several years ago, basketball’s concern was such that the exclusive terms of his AIS scholarship were relaxed in the hope of keeping him in the program.
Naitanui, too, was an extraordinary basketball talent.
But three years ago, Naitanui was selected in the WA under-16 football side, and selected more because of his eye-popping agility and overall athletic prowess than his performances to that point, and quickly made the elite, 30-player AFL/AIS academy.
According to the AFL’s national talent manager, Kevin Sheehan: It was after those experiences that he decided he wanted to be an AFL player.
Sheehan describes Watts, Naitanui and the likes of South Australian Hamish Hartlett, an outstanding representative cricketer who is expected to be a top-five selection today, as first-choice athletes.
It is a term that was born in 1995, when the then head of the AFL’s football operations, Ian Collins, wondered whether the league was doing enough, or anything much at all other than relying on cultural tradition, to attract players to the game.
He was inspired to ask the question by the emergence of Anthony Koutoufides, the Carlton superstar who left behind a career as an elite track athlete and the thought of being an Olympian to pursue football with Collo’s beloved Blues.
Kouta chose football but we weren’t sure many others like him were or would, Sheehan recalls.
Were we getting the first-choice athletes, who might be able to play our game?
The AFL’s response was to broaden and deepen its junior development system, to cover more ground, capture more players, involve them in an elite program closer in experience to the AFL system and sell the fact that with almost 700 players on AFL lists in any season, the prospect of a career was strong.
National under 16 and under 18 championships were created, as were the AIS and state-based academies that can give players three years of representative football and more than 200 hours a year of specialist coaching and education.
It was a moment of particular satisfaction for the AFL three years ago when it was discovered that 16 of the 30 teenagers in its AFL/AIS academy had represented either the country or their states in other sports.
Like West Coast’s Shannon Hurn who, to date, has enjoyed a modest career but was described by South Australian cricket selector John Nash as the state’s best prospect in a decade before he was drafted in 2005.
Chris Masten, another Eagle, was a nationally ranked track athlete when he was drafted last year as was the Western Bulldogs’ Andrejs Everitt the year before.
Carlton’s Bryce Gibbs played junior volleyball for Australia and the number one picks in the national drafts of 2004 and 2005, Brett Deledio and Marc Murphy, were team-mates in the Victorian under 17 cricket team before football claimed them.
If this must sound and feel to other codes and sports like an assault, Sheehan says the battle is to be won subtly.
We know that the talented kids will play two or three sports and our research indicates that they will be in talent squads and state squads in two or three sports, Sheehan says.
But that’s not to say we actively discourage them from playing or considering a career in other sports.
Playing other sports can even make them better footballers.